San Francisco’s success on the prime of the 2019 draft has created a little bit of an issue for the group.
Nick Bosa and Deebo Samuel have confirmed themselves to be two of the highest younger gamers at their positions.
Now the 49ers have to determine if they’ll pay each or if it’s time to maneuver on from one among their younger stars.
Right here is why San Francisco ought to select to not pay Nick Bosa.
1. Damage historical past
Nick Bosa has a prolonged harm historical past that dates to highschool, the place he tore an ACL his senior season. Extra just lately, Bosa has missed all however 5 video games in two of his final 4 seasons.
2. Lack of manufacturing
Bosa’s sack complete over the previous two years (15.5) is dwarfed by T.J. Watt’s complete during the last two years (37.5).
The 49ers will not be prepared to provide Bosa the quantity of assured cash he’s searching for, contemplating his harm historical past and total lack of manufacturing the final two seasons. Watt at present is on the prime of the sting rusher market, signing a brand new four-year deal final 12 months, which included $80 million assured.
Earlier than you suppose I’ve fully misplaced my thoughts, the above was primarily written in jest.
Each above factors have been used just lately for instance why Deebo Samuel shouldn’t be given near the highest contract at his place, all whereas many proceed to make the other case for Nick Bosa.
Listed below are the details as I see them:
Deebo Samuel and Nick Bosa are particular abilities.
Solely Jerry Rice produced extra yards as a rookie amongst 49ers broad receivers than Samuel in 2019. By way of the primary eight weeks of 2021, Samuel was on tempo for 1,766 receiving yards; this may have ranked second all-time in San Francisco historical past to, you guessed it, Jerry Rice.
The full additionally would have been forward of these of Davante Adams, Tyreek Hill, and Stefon Diggs a season in the past, the three receivers who’ve obtained massive paydays already this offseason.
Bosa completed with 9.5 sacks and was named NFL Defensive Rookie of the 12 months as a rookie. After lacking all however 5 quarters of the 2020 season attributable to a torn ACL, Bosa returned to publish 15.5 sacks.
Each have intensive harm histories, which makes signing both to prolonged contracts with giant ensures dangerous.
Bosa and Samuel every handled a number of accidents all through their school careers. Additionally they every missed vital time attributable to harm in 2020.
It takes a leap of religion to provide both of those two vital contracts.
The 49ers are unlikely to seek out replacements via the draft for years to come back.
San Francisco went over 20 years between hitting on a large receiver within the draft. Terrell Owens, drafted in 1996, is the one receiver chosen by the 49ers who comes near the expertise of Samuel.
It’s an analogous state of affairs at defensive finish. Earlier than choosing Bosa, Aldon Smith was the final cross rusher with the sort of expertise. Drafted in 2011, Smith terrorized opposing quarterbacks earlier than his profession in San Francisco was lower quick. Earlier than Smith, Charles Haley was the final nice 49ers cross rusher. Haley was drafted in 1986.
Each Nick Bosa and Deebo Samuel are price of receiving contracts that put them close to the highest of their place.
For Nick Bosa, the highest of the market assure would require the 49ers to go over $80 million assured. The full assure for Deebo Samuel would must be better than $72.2 million.
The biggest assure ever given by San Francisco is $74.1 million obtained by Jimmy Garoppolo in 2018.
Now I’d like to listen to from you. Ought to the 49ers give each Nick Bosa and Deebo Samuel new contracts close to the highest of their place?
If not, who deserves it, and why?
