I all the time surprise the place a number of the extra frequent misconceptions in our professions got here from. One, specifically, is the idea that in case your knees move your toes, it’s unhealthy in your knees.
That’s such a shortsighted and broad assertion.
However, slightly than asking if a motion is sweet or unhealthy, perhaps we should always simply perceive the biomechanics and stress?
To view extra episodes, subscribe, and ask your questions, go to mikereinold.com/askmikereinold.
#AskMikeReinold Episode 275: Knees Over Toes – Is it Actually Dangerous?
Hear and Subscribe to Podcast
You need to use the participant beneath to hearken to the podcast or subscribe. If you’re having fun with the podcast, PLEASE click on right here to depart us a evaluation in iTunes, it would actually imply rather a lot to us. THANKS!
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Podcasts | Spotify | | Extra
Present Notes
Transcript
Kim Lai:
Ryan from Massachusetts requested, are you able to talk about the knees over toes debate? Do you let individuals do actions like squats and lunges with their knees going over their toes? And does it change relying on the individual’s sport, objectives, or earlier harm?
Mike Reinold:
Ooh, we get one other debate. We’re going to dispel extra debates or myths right here. In order that’s humorous the knees over toes, I all the time surprise. Let’s begin the episode of this, the knees over toe debate, I assume is that lots of people or some individuals prior to now, there’s a standard false impression most likely on the market that individuals say that in case you do an exercise like a squat or lung or step kind motion and your knee interprets, you bend your knee a lot that it interprets over your toes. So assuming you’re getting depth that it places loads of stress in your knee joint, it’s an excessive amount of stress. Lots of people say, don’t let your knees move your toes. That’s a quite common sort of phrase. Proper? So I’ll begin the episode off with this and simply say like, I simply all the time surprise if that is a type of issues that social media, and perhaps even some early profession professionals, take this a little bit too severe, proper?
Mike Reinold:
Which means, no one actually thinks your knees are going to explode in the event that they go up over your toes. Even the primary individual that ever mentioned that, most likely didn’t say that that is a type of issues that I feel any individual took too far. Proper? So in each methods, there’s most likely some individuals within the medical neighborhood and health neighborhood that took it too far and mentioned that you realize you need to by no means go knees over toes. However I’d say the overwhelming majority of individuals perceive that’s a little bit extreme. So I really feel like this debate has most likely been a little bit bit extra sensationalized, however Dan Pope you most likely get requested this query rather a lot on-line and also you most likely are concerned in these discussions most likely greater than any of us proper right here. What do you assume? Do you need to give your two cents on this?
Dan Pope:
Yeah, for certain. I feel it actually simply comes all the way down to physics and the best approach to clarify it for me is; let’s say a squat, proper? So if I’m going right into a squat and I’ve had my knees touring ahead rather a lot over my toes, in case you have a look at your heart of mass and you then have a look at the place the knees are, you’ll have a second arm, proper? After which in case you have a look at your heart mass to your hips, you’ve got one other second arm. And in case you sit your hips actually far again, the second arm grows for the hips. And when you’ve got your knees actually far ahead, the stress goes to go extra on the knees since you improve the second arm there, proper? So clearly in life, you must have your knees go over your toes, however the extra the knee ahead out of your heart of a mass, the extra your quad and your knee, proper? And whenever you say knee, there’s a number of joints in there. In order that’s even nuanced. There’s extra stress on that knee, proper?
Dan Pope:
And in case you work in a inhabitants, let’s say of Olympic weightlifters, two issues; one deep squats are necessary, and also you’re going to have a ton of anterior knee translation. These going to return approach far ahead. And also you additionally need to be very function whenever you catch a snatch or a clear. And people two issues are going to place a ton of stress on the knee. And if I by no means put together my athlete for that, I’m going to run into some bother, proper? I feel the problem happens, and this occurred to me as a energy coach or a private coach, when somebody has knee ache, you determine actual fast, okay, if I had that knee journey ahead, it hurts them. Proper. After which if I simply ship their hips again, they really feel phenomenal. Proper?
Dan Pope:
So it’s sort of like, wow, I fastened my consumer’s ache by having them sit again. That have to be the reply. When in actuality and at the very least in bodily remedy literature, when you’ve got, let’s say patella tendinopathy. I’m certain in case you’ve seen step downs are tremendous, tremendous efficient for issues like patella tendinopathy. So a part of it’s that in case you keep away from having the knee come ahead when you’ve got knee ache, it looks like successful. However on the finish of the day, if you must get again to deeper squats, you then most likely need to have that knee come ahead. On the finish of the day, it comes all the way down to the individual. So if I’ve a daily individual that simply likes to work out within the gymnasium and have the ability to play with their youngsters, I don’t know that I have to push that knee ahead.
Dan Pope:
You recognize, I don’t must, we have been simply speaking about knees over toe man. He has loads of nice workouts, however I feel from the vast majority of common people with knee ache, you’d most likely explode their kneecaps. In case you tried that as a primary motion, you realize what I imply? So a part of it’s that it’s a must to discover ways to dose your workouts. After which precisely, as you mentioned, it’s a must to work out the wants of the individual in entrance of you and slowly work in direction of that, and permit ache to be a little bit of your information as they proceed to progress over time.
Lenny Macrina:
Additionally Mike, you talked about earlier that social media has influenced us a little bit. I see it the opposite approach too, the place early profession professionals, newer grads, newer PTs try to drive this on sufferers; to do the knees over toe factor as a result of it’s secure and we acquired to do it as a result of it’s secure with out the individual essentially being educated or needing to have that of their life.
Lenny Macrina:
Now don’t get me fallacious, going up and down steps, and basic items of life would require you must go over your toes. It’s like that, however perhaps to not the extent that dosing it and performing it weighted with like a sissy squat or issues like that. And attempting to principally drive it on our sufferers. Once more, I do it, I deal with loads of ACLs. We acquired to get their knees over their toes to have the ability to obtain their weight and get their quads going and get them snug in that place. However I simply assume generally it’s going the opposite approach, too, the place we’re attempting to push on individuals. Trigger we all know it’s secure, particularly for everyone, it doesn’t really feel good for some individuals. So that you simply sort of again off.
Mike Reinold:
Simply the truth that it is a dialog about, is it good or unhealthy or secure or unsafe is hilarious.
Lenny Macrina:
Proper.
Mike Reinold:
I actually assume it’s a small, perhaps like 20% of the individuals really assume that is secure or unsafe everyone else, in my thoughts. Perhaps I’m taking this with no consideration. Everyone else simply realizes that it’s not a secure or a great or a nasty difficulty. It’s a spectrum. It’s simply mechanics, individuals, it’s simply biomechanics. Proper? This isn’t about reconciling ache. That is about biomechanics, proper? And the extra your knee goes ahead and the extra you bend, the extra stress it’s, that’s it. Stress is sweet. Stress is unhealthy. Stress could be good till it’s unhealthy. Stress could be unhealthy till it’s good. Proper? Stress is stress, proper? It’s simply stress. And it’s a must to put these variables collectively.
Mike Reinold:
Some persons are prepared for stress. Some individuals have to steadily load into stress. Some individuals need to keep away from stress. Proper? So the truth that this turns into a debate, after which what occurs is rather like every thing else, like I mentioned, it confuses the heck out of everyone is you’ve got individuals saying they really like taking a look at therapists which might be avoiding deep knee positions and shaming them saying they’re “oh my God, they’re so old style in retro”. I’m having have a look at me, I get my whole knee affected person, she’s doing a pistol squad proper now. Take a look at how good she’s doing. Proper? That’s too far on that finish. However then the person who’s like, “Oh, by no means let your knees as a result of your knee will blow up.” That’s that’s too far on that finish too.
Mike Reinold:
So such as you simply acquired to simply take a step again and say, this isn’t about good or unhealthy or secure or unsafe. It’s only a biomechanical precept that Dan talked about with the second arms that claims the deeper you go, the extra stress you apply. And it’s a must to decide does the individual in entrance of you, are they prepared for that stress? And do they want that stress of their life? And in the event that they do, how will we construct them up for that? Proper? Is it actually that straightforward? What do you assume, Dave? I need to hear your thoughts on this.
Dave:
Yeah, I feel, I imply, I feel Dan mentioned one of the necessary issues, threaded in there may be like this actually all comes all the way down to understanding somebody’s objectives and what they need to get out of their health and their life. Proper. Like I feel the opposite one is sort of associated to that is like Jefferson curl comes up a ton with like me and gymnastics and persons are like, oh, like ever desires you to do Jefferson curls as a result of gymnast like, perhaps they’re doing them and probably not really it’s like not an excellent fashionable factor. However in case you take somebody, such as you mentioned, who simply likes doing calisthenics and physique weight kind actions they usually assume it appears to be like tremendous superior to do that excessive sissy squat, to love seven plates of depth and are available again up. It’s like, if that’s their aim, then like, cool.
Dave:
Perhaps it’s a two yr aim for them. And perhaps they do need to work on that stuff, however they don’t have any aim of, of again squatting an excellent heavy weight or enjoying baseball or sprinting or reducing or pivoting or doing all kinds of different stuff that, that quantity of mobility with out loads of good additional energy on high of it is perhaps problematic. So, it’s actually all again to love what individuals need. Like, is there a sure one that may actually need that? Certain. Then perhaps that’s an ideal development of workouts over a pair years for another person who, like Dan mentioned, like I simply need to decide my youngsters up and squat down and never have my knees harm. It’s most likely not an excellent possibility for them, as a result of they’ve a protracted historical past of issues that perhaps don’t really feel nice.
Dave:
And I feel it’s the scenario the place I feel generally therapists or individuals on the web identical to get a little bit bit too dogmatic and say that it’s all the time black or white. And when in actuality it’s actually about what the individual desires in entrance of you and also you simply acquired to hearken to them and use the right software for them that you’ve.
Mike Reinold:
Yeah. I imply, I don’t assume lets say that a lot better with like, all of it simply comes again to the individual in entrance of you, however I’d actually, actually, actually love to simply get out of this debate of like are you able to do it or not? Proper. And like Lenny and I get this with like weighted baseball coaching in baseball, proper? They’re like our baseballs unhealthy, our weighted baseballs unhealthy? I’m like, no, they’re not unhealthy. They’re not good both. Proper. They’re however they modify the stress. So every thing we do adjustments the stress utilized and also you simply have to understand, do you need to change the stress utilized? And when has that change into an excessive amount of or too little within the individual in entrance of you. Proper. And identical to and cease getting in these conversations and these items about is one thing secure or unsafe. The whole lot has a spectrum of security. The whole lot has a secure spectrum of load. Proper. And we simply have to love apply that and put that collectively. Proper. Make sense. Superior. However anyone else on that? I imply, I do know that is sort of like such a preferred factor on the web. I need to guarantee that we, we deal with it, however, Diwesh from the energy coaching perspective, like what, what are your ideas?
Diwesh Poudyal:
Yeah. So I’ve two ideas on this. One I do assume this general concept of precept undoubtedly got here from the bodily remedy realm after which any health, skilled energy, coach, private coach that wished to maintain an eye fixed out on their purchasers to guarantee that they’re doing stuff secure or they’re not hurting individuals. I feel they, they’re most likely those that took it actually far, at the very least within the health neighborhood. Proper.
Mike Reinold:
Proper.
Diwesh Poudyal:
So, you sort of talked about that, like,
Mike Reinold:
I really feel such as you’re proper although. I really feel just like the health neighborhood nearly like is the one which like, the PTs are like, whoa, we didn’t say like that for like everyone on a regular basis, proper. I really feel like there’s a false impression someplace right here. Proper. There’s somebody miscommunicated, however yeah, you’re proper. I feel the, the health crowd heard it as soon as. Proper. And so they have been identical to, man, what, and the medical professionals, they’re loopy all that they are saying, you may by no means do this. I don’t assume that’s true, however yeah. Sorry, preserve going.
Diwesh Poudyal:
Yeah. It’s like maddening to assume what number of energy coaches will attempt to push individuals to hit like a deep, like all-time low squat with out letting their knees go previous their toes and like sitting approach again. And so they begin cranking on hips and like giving individuals again ache and stuff. But it surely, like is unquestionably a giant, massive level within the health trade. And I do know if there certain was once I was studying these things rising up, however that was sort of my first level. I, I do assume within the health neighborhood, there’s much more training to be accomplished. Like, I really like that Dan talked concerning the biomechanics was simply the lever arm and the second arm from the knee to the hip in comparison with your heart of mass. Like I feel simply understanding that for lots of private trainers and energy coach is tremendous necessary.
Diwesh Poudyal:
Trigger I’m prepared to wager you want, they’ve by no means actually thought of it that approach. Proper. In order that was sort of like my first level, the second level being, I sort of talked about the wants evaluation for our earlier query, however Dave and Dan sort of talked about like, what are the calls for of help on the finish of the day? Like loads of athletic actions, like sprinting, particularly in acceleration, even reduce leaping, prefer it all requires fairly a little bit of ahead knee journey. And I feel the largest factor for us to bear in mind is like, what, what does that individual have entry to? So far as their kinematics mixed? Like, what does their ankle dorsal flection seem like? Have they got a ton of dors choice? So that they, they want to have the ability to management all that dors flection or they, don’t have loads of dors flection.
Diwesh Poudyal:
Like, ought to we let individuals have their heels come up off the bottom to carry out that knee previous toe squat? In all probability not. However in case you’re somebody like me, for instance, like me and Dan discuss this on a regular basis, like bragging about my dors flection, however I’ve dors flection the place I’ve six inches previous my toes. Proper. And like I’ve tremendous lengthy shins. Like I’ve to have my knees fairly far previous my, to, to hit a all-time low squat as a result of I need to do Olympic weight lifting and, heavy again squats and entrance squats and stuff. So it undoubtedly does come all the way down to the wants of no matter exercise or sport, but additionally what do they really have entry to for whole motion? After which perhaps let’s attempt to construct some energy and lively management there.
Mike Reinold:
I find it irresistible. I find it irresistible. Okay. And I feel, the final sort of idea I feel you will get from this episode is that like, there isn’t a one reply for every thing and there’s no is one thing secure or unsafe. It’s all a spectrum. Proper. And it’s a must to preserve that in thoughts. And most of these items like, knees over the toe is a good instance. All it does is it simply adjustments the stress and it’s a must to decide for that individual in entrance of you is the suitable, is the stress value it. Proper? After which how do you slowly construct a program to get you to that time the place they’ll then management that stress? And I feel that’s the actual aim. Dan’s athletes, lots of people that work with Diwesh within the gymnasium, proper. They, they need to get to depth of their squat.
Mike Reinold:
So we’ve got to get them there. Proper. However that doesn’t imply you leap proper there, however we’ve got to construct a program to get them there as a result of that’s their purposeful exercise. Proper. Not everyone wants that. So we don’t go that deep with that individual. However I feel it’s, it’s not a lot the dialog of secure or unsafe. It’s extra about stress. Proper. And I feel if we will take nearly all of those debates about it, one thing good or unhealthy, I feel the reply is that every thing could be good and every thing and be unhealthy. It simply will depend on the way you apply it. Proper. So hopefully that helps. Good query, Ryan. I like that one. You recognize, when you’ve got questions like that, I imply, I perceive how these items could be complicated for those who are simply attempting to study these items, since you hear some very like, you hear opinions, proper?
Mike Reinold:
You hear like these ideas and also you surprise like, is that this a much bigger downside on the market? I do know there’s some individuals on the market that hear an idea and assume like the entire world is anxious about this debate. When actually it’s most likely solely 20% of the world that really thinks it is a debate. The opposite 80% really assume it’s only a, that stress equation that we talked about. So I can see how that be daunting for any individual. So, thanks Ryan. If in case you have a query like that, head to mikereinold.com, click on on that podcast hyperlink and preserve asking away and please go to iTunes, Spotify, subscribe, and charge and evaluation us. So we preserve doing these episodes to reply your questions. Thanks a lot.
